Using video on the Web
Index
- Introduction
- What works well on video?
- Types of video presentation
- Key considerations
- Producing a video
- Managing digital assets
Introduction
The Net is now realising its long-heralded potential as a video medium, and video's use has increased greatly across all age groups. It’s a powerful format, and the popularity of video-heavy sites like YouTube and Facebook mean its something many users expect to see.
As noted in our Time-based media under WCAG2.0 guide, video (and multimedia in general) has the potential to further open up the Web to many disabled users. On the other hand, inaccessible multimedia will lock them out. Because of this, this guide also draws attention to the web standards in this area.
This guide is based on work by the Ministry of Education.
What works well on video?
Presentations and speeches
These include internal and external presentations or speeches and announcements.
- Tip: Where a video is of one person talking, keep it interesting by having images spliced in.
- Example: The MacDowell Exhibition from the Library of Congress. Note use of transcript and captions.
Uploaded video from a DVD or TV clip
Video material originally created for offline use can reach a wider audience on the web.
- Tip: Make sure you let the development company know at the start of the project that you will also require a clip for the web (more efficient than trying to rip a video from a DVD or TV clip afterwards).
- Example: The Chosen Ones (SPARC)
Anything that can be told as a story
Examples:
- Digital stories on the Te Kete Ipurangi Curriculum website (requires Quicktime)
- New Zealand History Online (New Zealand History Net).
Instructional guides - how to do something
- Example: Single poi (Te Kete Ipurangi)
Anything with a strong audio-visual element
- Example: Music video on Fuelled 4 School
Types of video presentation
Be creative. Explore video sites and their categories, particularly ones that present similar types of material. As well as more traditional filming, consider the following options.
Flash movie with animated graphics
Example: edu2.0 (DotSub)
Video of a paper presentation
Fun to watch; quick and cheap to make.
Example: Social media in plain English (YouTube)
Screencast
This is essentially a movie of what a user sees on their monitor ad is good for demonstrating software. There are free programs you can use to create a screencast, as well as commercial products.
A presentation where items of interest are filmed
Filming images on a PC or chart on a wall is a cheaper option than editing in images. It also keeps the focus on the speaker.
A video with text added to reinforce the key messages
Example: Teaching and learning at Takapuna Grammar (TKI)
Key considerations
- Video clips should be short (a rough guideline is no more than 1 minute per clip).
- Tell people how long each video clip is. To avoid confusion, we recommend using this format: 35 sec, 1:45.
- Long presentations should be segmented, with segments available from a menu (but you don’t need to make the whole presentation into video clips; consider using a few clips showing important parts, and having the rest as text with images). See Dealing with long presentations below.
- Provide an image (eg, thumbnail) and summary (preview) next to the video link, so the person has some information to use when deciding whether to open the file. (The video company can extract still images during production. Ask them to provide about three still images for each clip, so you can choose.)
- Remember accessibility and the web standards. See the Time-based media under WCAG2.0 web guide.
File formats, bandwidth and user devices
It is important to provide different options when you put your video on the web, so it can be accessed by people:
- using different kinds of media player
- on both dial-up and broadband
- using different user devices
File formats
Popular media players include Windows Media Player (which is not cross-platform and will not play all file types by default), iTunes, Real Player and Quicktime (which are all cross-platform). Increasingly, video is being presented in Flash – eg, via an embedded Flash player. It is estimated that 98 to 99% of internet users have Flash.
- If you choose to provide video in Windows Media format (ie, .wmv), ensure you also provide a file in an open format for people with other players (MPEG-4 format - ie, .mp41 is recommended).
- If you choose to provide video in MPEG-4 format, consider also providing a file in Windows Media format (many people have only Windows Media player installed; and you want to avoid requiring them to install a player especially to watch your video).
Bandwidth
It is important to ensure your video is accessible for people with different connection speeds. People with fast internet may not appreciate having to wait for a video to download, while people on dial-up or with poor broadband are likely to find streaming video disjointed and frustrating. Therefore, you should:
- Provide a streaming version of the clip, and
- Let people know that if they are on dial-up or slow broadband, they can right-click on the link to download the video. (Alternatively, you could provide a downloadable version of the video clip on the page – but your page may become cluttered and confusing if you provide too many options.)
User devices
People may access your video using devices other than a desktop PC or notebook. Mobile phones, iPods, Palm pilots (and more) may be used to view your video. It may be useful to talk to your provider about options for these users.
Presenting video on launch pages
The following are options for presenting video information, links etc on a launch page.
Template example 1: Embedded Flash movie
In the method shown in this example, progressive enhancement is used to automatically provide a video option that best suits the user, based on the software they have installed:
JavaScript is used to detect whether a visitor has the right Flash plugin (and JavaScript).
- If they do, an embedded Flash movie is provided via a Flash player that has been built for the site.
- If they do not, the person may be given the option of installing/upgrading their software. If they choose not to or the option is not provided, baseline functionality is provided – in this case, it would be an image linking to a downloadable video file.
Education for Enterprise [title]
Education for Enterprise builds on the unique perspectives, values and ideas that are part of our national identity, promoting leadership and innovation. (58 sec)
Transcript
- Education for Enterprise (HTML) [link]
Template example 2: Non-embedded video
How to use an RSS feed [title]
Video clip 1: Setting up an RSS reader
Length: 55 sec
Summary
Zoe Zimmermann explains how an RSS reader works and demonstrates how to set up an account in Google Reader.
Watch the video
- Setting up an RSS reader (for Quicktime, iTunes, RealPlayer)
- Setting up an RSS reader (for Windows Media Player)
Slow connection? We recommend downloading this video (right-click on the appropriate link or click on the link while holding down a modifier key: Windows = Alt, Mac = Command).
Transcript
- Setting up an RSS reader (HTML) [link]
Download
- Download a player (Technical help page) [link]
Notes:
- Remember that your links should be unique and descriptive.
- The top link opens an .mp4 file; the second link opens a .wmv file.
- Make sure your "Technical help" section or page has information about downloading media players. If you don’t have a technical help section, put the information at the bottom of the page the videos are on. (However, it is best to have it in one place on the site, and link to it whenever you provide a video.)
Template example 3: Embedded YouTube video
In this example, the primary video is hosted on YouTube (which provides video in Flash format). The example below shows an embedded YouTube video; however, you can also provide a text link to the video if you prefer. See the information that follows for points to consider when using YouTube video.
Te Matatini 2009 Kapa Haka festival [title]
Check out Tauira mai Tawhiti mai te rohe o Mataatua with their waiata tira...kia ora ra e te whanau! (Length: 2:17)
Transcript
[Text of transcript on same page (recommended) OR link to transcript (as below)]
Tauira mai Tawhiti mai te rohe o Mataatua’s waiata tira (HTML) [link]
Template example 4
In this example, the primary video is hosted on YouTube in Flash format.
Surfing safety
Video clip 1: How to fall
Length: 2:17
Summary
Mike Tetherick demonstrates the art of the peaceful wipe out.
Watch the video at YouTube
Video: How to fall (Flash) [link]
Transcript
How to fall (HTML) [link]
Download
Download a Flash player (Technical help page) [link]
YouTube: Considerations
There are some important things consider about YouTube.
- There is a potential conflict between the YouTube terms of service and the indemnity provision in Section 65ZC of the Public Finance Act.
- YouTube displays "Related material" and Search options at the end of a video – these may be inappropriate (however, at present YouTube has a new option that allows you to turn them off when you upload a video).
- You do not have control about the way YouTube displays the video – eg, in future advertising could be displayed.
"Technical help" information
Make sure your "Technical help" section or page has information about downloading media players. If you don’t have a technical help section, put the information at the bottom of the page the videos are on. However, it is best to have it in one place on the site, and link to it whenever you provide a video.
Dealing with long presentations
When putting a long presentation (eg, a TV programme or keynote speech) on the web, don’t try to put up one long video file. Consider one of the following:
- Present the video in small segments. You might use a video player with functionality to present a number of related clips, or you could usea standard webpage with each segment listed and a short summary and thumbnail for each).
- Put the material on the web in multiple formats – eg, a combination of:
- still images
- a transcript
- a quote
- a comic strip-like sequence of photos with captions
- a powerpoint presentation with notes or voice-over
- a couple of video clips of the most interesting parts of the presentation.
Getting a web video from a DVD or TV clip
If you’re making a DVD or TV production (eg, an advertising clip), let the company know at the start of the project that you will also require clips for the web, in .wmv and .mp4 format. While a clip can probably be created from any playable source, it is likely to be more efficient to have your clips created from the source file, and you will be assured of a good quality result.
Presenting your video on the web in an engaging way
If you’re not using a video player, make use of images, extracts and quotes on your web page to present the video in a way that makes people want to find out more. (Get the company that produces the video to take about three still shots from the video during production for use on your webpage.)
Example:
- The Chosen Ones (SPARC)
If you have time and budget, you could consider getting your web development company to make a Flash video ‘player’ that sits on your web page (the video is "embedded").
Making video accessible
Video must meet the web standards (see the Time-based media under WCAG2.0 guide). In most cases, a transcript and captions must be provided. In a few cases, audio descriptions must be added.
Captioning
Captions differ from subtitles. Subtitles are provided for visual people who speak a different language, while captions aim to describe all significant audio content – ie, spoken dialogue and non-speech information such as the identity of speakers and their manner of speaking, and music and sound effects.
Captions are not needed if the video presents no more information than is already presented in text (or in text alternatives – eg, alt text). In other words, if the video itself is an alternative format (eg, provided as an extra option for people with cognitive, language, or learning disabilities) then it does not need to be captioned.
Resources
Captioning instructions
- Captioning Quicktime (WebAim)
- Captioning RealPlayer (WebAim)
- Captioning Windows Media (WebAim)
- Captions for Video with Flash CS3 (Digital Web Magazine)
- Closed-Captioned Video in Flash (Layers Magazine)
Captioning Flash on YouTube
- Getting Started: Captions / Subtitles (Youtube)
- Closed Caption Videos (YouTube)
Captioning software
- Subtitle Workshop (free, multi-format subtitle editing tool)
- Software for making captions (WebAim)
WCAG2.0 techniques
- Captions (Prerecorded) (W3C)
Online captioning
- DotSub is a collaborative captioning project
- Project ReadOn and Overstream are two of a number of other sites that also provide captioning functionality (but require that they host the video).
Closed captioning vs open captioning
Closed
The word "closed" in closed captioning indicates that not all viewers see the captions - only those who choose to decode or activate them. On the other hand, "open captions" (sometimes called "burned-in" or "hard-coded" captions) are visible to all viewers.
Example of closed captioning:
Example: Barack Obama (barackobama.com)
Open captioning
Open captions are a permanent part of the video. They can get blurry when the video is compressed. Use closed captioning where possible. If the video is to be hosted on a site where closed captioning is not possible, you may need to use open captioning.
Writing captions
Say who is talking:
- Tana: So team up and make learning fun!
Include significant audio:
- [dog barking]
- [laughter]
- [music playing]
Note tone any other relevant factors:
- [mocking]
- [shouting]
- [British accent]
Length: Keep captions short: longer captions take too long to read and may display over several lines (so could obscure the picture).
Duration: Ensure the caption displays for long enough to be read. A short caption needs at least two seconds.
Formatting: Use a font, colour and size that will render well onscreen and be legible against the background. Avoid italics BUT if you decide to use it, choose a font with a true italic style rather than slanted text (which can get pixellated). Think about where the captions will best be positioned – don’t necessarily go with the default positioning.
Transcripts
General tips
- Write a full transcript (not a summary).
- Identify each speaker.
- Where appropriate, describe what is happening (eg, what the person is doing) (ie, cover the visual element for blind users).
- Don’t include unnecessary words such as ‘um’ or ‘er’, or repetitions.
- Ideally, place the transcript on the same page (eg, under the video player). Another option is to use a text link that says "Transcript".
Example transcript
A ‘hot extraction’ of a soldier from the jungle – interview with Brian Senn (New Zealand History Online)
Automatically-generated transcripts
Sometimes voice/speech recognition software can be used during video production to make a transcript. However, this is likely to be effective only if there is just one person talking. Talk to the company that is producing your video about this. Make sure you check a software-generated transcript carefully.
Producing a video
Talking with your provider
Consider asking your provider to include the following information in the video itself:
- Captions and an audio description (if required)
- The title (and any section subtitles) – these are inserted at the editing stage.
- Any required acknowledgements or related text. If the video will be hosted on another site, you need to ensure you meet the government copyright requirements. Options may be to include a copyright statement at the end of the video, or (if possible) to provide a link back to the copyright statement on your site. Note, you don’t need a copyright statement if the video is on your site: because the video is part of your site’s content, it is covered by the site’s copyright statement
- Any images or related clips you want to include. Graphs, examples (and so on) can be edited in, along with extracts from related videos. Try to do this if your video is of one person talking; it will help add interest and keep the viewer’s attention. See the MacDowell Exhibition video – this is primarily narration, but is broken up by graphics showing examples.
Setting up the studio
It is important to consider the background before you start videoing – even if the video is being shot by professionals or made in a professional studio.
- Web users are very easily distracted, so if your video is fairly static (eg, involves one person talking), set up the room so distracting elements are out of the frame of the video. An example may be a video of someone making an announcement. Set up a plain background, or take advantage of the opportunity by including your agency's promotional material in the background.
- Video captures things that are lying around or going on in the background, and this can expose your agency to risk. Even when using professionals to create a video, always ensure that what is shown in the background is material or behaviour that can safely go public without causing embarrassment to your agency. Remember that with downloadable video, people can (and do) go through it frame by frame.
Acceptance of the final product
When you get your video clips from the provider:
- Check that they are in the correct formats
- Watch each clip right through and check the quality (eg, titles are clear, picture is reasonably clear). Over-compression can cause poor quality and often providers are able to improve this.
Privacy
Respect the rights and privacy of people you are having filmed, even if they are in the background. Make sure you have permission from everyone that appears, to use them in the video. This is particularly important for children – get permission from their parents or guardians.
When seeking permission:
- Make sure you outline to the person very clearly where and how the video will be used (eg, on the ministry’s xxx website as part of the xxx feature); and if possible, how long it will be there for. Also let them know that one or two still images from the video will be used as thumbnails alongside the clip.
- Consider asking the person how they feel about giving permission for extended use – eg, for the ministry to use the video clip, or extracts from it, or still images from it, on other ministry websites or in ministry publications, DVDs and so on.
- If a parent and their child is in the video, get separate permission for each.
Use a permissions template (your Communications team may be able to help with this) to record the information.
- Make sure it details very clearly what use the permission is being given for.
- There should be a date when the permission expires.
- Include contact details for the person or guardian (so they can be contacted if renewed permission or permission for a different use is required in the future).
- The permission form should be signed by the person giving permission.
File the permission form as part of the video record.
Managing digital assets
Video files are a valuable resource and it’s important to consider carefully how they will be stored and managed. Specialist companies may have established facilities where they can store material for you; talk to them about this at the start of a project – ask questions about where the material is stored, how long they keep it for, how they retrieve it (metadata) and what the costs are.
If you use a company that does not have storage facilities, ensure you get a copy of the original file from them as well as the final output. You agency should have an agreed practice for storing this type of material, which everyone follows.
An important consideration when looking at storing video material internally is capacity. Video files can be large and when there is an increasing number of them, they can require an alarming amount of file space. It is recommended that you talk to your agency’s records group and IT team about possible solutions.
- See Managing web information as records and archiving websites (Web guide).



